You Can See Everything

“Thirty-four days before she’s sent to prison, notorious Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes invites a skeptical film crew to document her every move. What begins as an intimate portrait becomes a mind-bending three-year journey.”

**I highly recommend knowing nothing more about this film before seeing it, to preserve the experience**

Almost no filmmaker gets my brain firing like Nathan Fielder’s work does. From Nathan For You to The Curse to The Rehearsal, Nathan’s filmed output is as hilarious as it is bizarre as it is provoking.

So of course, when his mysterious and riveting minute-long teaser trailer featuring the infamous Elizabeth Holmes appeared online last month, I circled opening weekend on my calendar.

When I walked into the theater for the first showing on Saturday morning, I found myself in a sold-out auditorium, surrounded by fellow Angeleno moths drawn to the flame of the newest A24 film. It made for a buzzy pre-show.

Given that my history with Nathan’s work (as well as his co-director Lance Oppenheim) has left me slack-jawed, I prepared for this experience by bringing scratch paper into the theater, ready to take notes during the three-hour film.

What I’ve transcribed below are stream of consciousness thoughts that stood out to me upon first viewing, bolstered in places with the appropriate context (buzzword!) Once again, Nathan was successful in leaving me with more questions than answers.

**Note: I did not refresh my memory on the specifics of Elizabeth Holmes and the Theranos scheme before watching this film**

  • “Liz” (as Elizabeth Holmes is frequently referred to in the film) and her partner Billy Evans have two children together; is Liz a good mom? Is Billy a good father?
  • Liz and Billy both speak like AI chat bots. Too agreeable when being pressed for answers, and they also have an answer for everything.
  • When Nathan presses Liz or Billy for an answer to an uncomfortable question, both are happy to change the subject, usually hiding behind their family and familial obligations.
  • Liz has terrific body language for someone who wants to sell you something. Always nodding her head while speaking, always smiling, always with enormous eyes that never blink.
  • Are Liz and Billy completely honest with each other when they’re alone? I suppose this implies that they’re constantly performing for Nathan and the film crew, which is very much up for debate. But to what degree are they this strange with one another? To what degree is one partner performing an act for the other?
  • “I just want to show [the product] works,” Liz says to Billy, who is also her partner in launching the Theranos 2.0 device. This is the problem with tech people – they’re so focused on the end point of success that they’ll do and say anything to get there. On top of that, the product seems awfully reminiscent of Theranos 1.0 …
  • To what degree does Billy view Liz herself as his Silicon Valley product/project?
  • “Can” vs “Capable”. There is a distinction.
  • We observe Billy obsessively watching chemistry videos on 2 or 3x speed, and then watch him regurgitate this new found information the next day on business calls to sell Theranos 2.0. How well does he know anything that he’s talking about? How common/uncommon is this amongst Silicon Valley types?
  • Even with flash photography, Liz never blinks! It’s off-putting.
  • The reason for the flash photography is she and Billy decide to get full imaging done of her so that a high-quality AI version of Liz can exist. What!?
  • The random scene of Billy completely full-frontal nude in the shower … WHAT!?
  • So … Liz is a sociopath, Billy is a psychopath? Is that about right? Regardless, they are a match made in heaven.
  • Liz communicates and controls through silence. She uses certain classic body language motions like she’s pressing a button where she knows what reaction she’ll get from the other person. She uses this for demands, like “Go away”. What works great here is that Nathan is immune to this and allows her silence to become awkward as he waits to see what she’ll do in response.
  • The fact that Liz’s father worked for Enron, and then later we see Billy working out of a WeWork office are fascinating details. Adding to that, Nathan became famous in the United States for his TV show Nathan For You, which was a reality-based comedy where he helped failing businesses with whacky schemes. Obviously Theranos 1.0 was one of the most famous failed businesses of this century.
  • What does Liz’s mom think of all this? The camera cuts to her a few times, even focusing on the anxiousness in her hands, but we never hear so much as a peep from her.
  • Liz has a number of phone conversations about what prison will be like – how much influence did she have on going to the facility in Bryan, Texas for her imprisonment?
  • Wait do Nathan and Liz have sexual tension? Sexual chemistry?
  • The halfway point of the film flashes us forward two years, from 2023 to 2025. I guess that explains how this film hits its three-hour run time.
  • The family has moved from San Diego to central Texas to be near Liz while she’s serving her prison time. Billy and the kids have put down roots, and Billy seems to have assimilated into being a Texan, as we reacquaint ourselves with him at the shooting range.
  • Billy is loudly and constantly sniffling in the Texas portion of the film (he also seems to carry some new bloat in his face), which is no doubt accentuated in the film to imply regular drug usage.
  • To what degree has Billy moved past Liz, to what degree does he consider his Liz project “sunsetted”? It’s hard not to think he just used her so he could start a new company, and accumulate fame in the process. Billy does have the AI version of Liz on a screen looming over him as he works on his computer at the kitchen table.
  • Billy now owns at least one large lizard, and at least one large snake, but these reptiles are never directly referred to, we only seen them as essentially set decoration. Where did these things come from!?
  • The Texas house Billy lives in does not look like it’s built for kids at all. There are stepping stones to get to the front door, and Billy must carry his kids’ wheeled toys over the rocks to get them inside. This guy cares about the kids?
  • Billy says that he doesn’t need to ask Liz about what she’s thinking while in prison, because he knows her better than anybody. Billy says Liz just wants to “Build monuments of love to me.” Whoa.
  • After Liz reports to prison, she’s basically not featured again in an onscreen capacity. For this reason, Nathan enlists the actor Amanda Seyfried (who portrayed Liz in the Hulu show about the Theranos fraud called The Dropout) to both act as his confidant regarding his experience documenting Liz and Billy, and later to actually portray Liz once again in order to re-create interactions that Nathan and Lance didn’t get footage of. THIS is juicy, and frankly Amanda should get an acting nom for her work both in and out of character on this film.
  • Nathan’s most recent reality-based show, The Rehearsal, is one where he enlists civilians and actors alike to create and re-create scenarios so that specific social and professional situations can be practiced before they happen for real. Sort of a cognitive behavioral therapy situation, but taken to the extreme. The way Nathan deploys Amanda as an actor to inhabit Liz feels very much like a special one-off episode of the show.
  • One of the most memorable scenes in the film is when Amanda, Nathan and Billy have dinner at Billy’s Texas house. Things get heated as Amanda and Billy go back and forth about Liz, and while Amanda is somewhat compromised having played a fictionalized version of Liz in the Hulu show, Billy comes off as extremely self-involved and obtuse. Amanda pushes him a lot, especially after the incredible reveal that Billy has Power Of Attorney over Liz, who is very much still alive and of sound mind and body; Billy brushes this off like it’s normal, and does the same when he reveals he’s restarted Liz’s defunct TwitterX account (he admits the majority of messages are from him masquerading as her.) This dinner scene culminates with Amanda and Billy fighting about Charlie Kirk, probably the ultimate sign that Billy has gone full Texas.
  • The big question everyone will have watching this movie is how much of a victim is Liz? Wherever you land on that may be more of a reflection on you.
  • My big takeaway from the film is that so much of life is about where you draw the line in the sand to fight the battle. Liz and Billy use the word “context” a lot, asking for it from Nathan when he asks them difficult questions. They’re trying to understand why he’s asking the question, so they can determine where the line is that they need to defend.
  • Another massive question is, to what extent are fictionalized TV shows and fictionalized portrayals of people adding to the confusion of what is base truth? Liz says that everyone that she comes into contact with in prison only knows who she is from the Hulu show, and they believe it’s a documentary.
  • I’ve been careful not to call this film a documentary, because that’s not what it is, or what it’s trying to be. It’s prodding you to not take things at face value in the digital, social media, and AI age.

Epilogue:

After watching any film that rocks my world, I like to peruse Letterboxd and various Subreddits to read what other people think. In doing that for this film, I found a comment that was so clear-eyed and full-throated that I genuinely feel as if it shouldn’t be read until you’ve had a chance to enjoy thinking through the film on your own, because reading it will rob you of the process of thinking through various interpretations because of how correct it is.

But who cares do whatever you want.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *